from IsaDora ..

Well i would stay away from waterproof. They somtimes have chemicals that could make your eyes worse.Truly Natural Mascara is a very good prodect for people with allergies like you.You can also talk to a makeup specialist.They would probably have useful info.Good luck on your search.:)

Waterproof mascara always tends to make my eyes water even more. Boots has a mascara called No 7 Super Sensitive Mascara. It has a gentle
ph balance and is also great for contact lens wearers. You can ONLY purchase it on line.
http://www.us.boots.com/Supersensitivemascara/

I would recommend Physicians Formula Organic Wear 100% Natural lash Boosting Mascara......it will also help maintain the strength of your lashes. It's around $10 so worth a try!

Thanks Faith!!! Can I only buy it online, or does like Whole Foods maybe sell??

Yes hypro allergenic and also try more of a gel based mascara and not a wax or oil based. I think origins carries a great one too.

I would stay away from waterproof. The ingredients they have to use to make it waterproof are toxic.

What you want, is a mascara made from all natural ingredients.
www.honeybeegardens.com
Truly Natural Mascara for $10. This is a seriously good product. My sister has bad allergies and wears contacts, and this is the only mascara that has ever worked for her. It performs beautifully, never flakes, etc.